The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to The Wishing Well Bar & Grill on A, a local gem nestled in Black Creek, WI. Renowned for its inviting atmosphere and friendly service, this restaurant offers a delightful menu that caters to various tastes. Highlights include their famous Friday fish fry, featuring irresistibly fresh fish sandwiches like broiled haddock and perch, celebrated by patrons for their quality and flavor.

For those craving something heartier, the diverse selection of sandwiches—including the juicy bacon cheeseburger and the savory ribeye steak sandwich—pairs perfectly with their crispy French fries. Pizza lovers can indulge their cravings with options like the Meat Lovers or the customizable Build Your Own pizza.

To complement your meal, be sure to explore their basket specials, such as popcorn shrimp and chicken tenders. Whether you're a local or just passing through, The Wishing Well promises a satisfying dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

The menu emphasizes classic bar and grill fare with a focus on broasted and grilled chicken dishes, as well as seafood options featured prominently in the Friday Fish Fry category. Pricing generally falls within a moderate range of $8 to $20, with appetizers and basket specials positioned as budget-friendly options under $10. Premium items include sizable seafood combos and plates, such as the $31.95 combo and $14.75 Pike Plate, indicating higher-value offerings for larger meals. The presence of a dedicated Friday Fish Fry suggests a specialty or peak service time centered around seafood dishes. Overall, the menu balance caters to both casual snacking and more substantial dining events.